How to Increase Average Order Value on Shopify: Top Strategies to Explore

In the competitive world of e-commerce, acquiring new customers can be expensive and time-consuming. 

Did you know that it costs 5-25 times more to acquire a new customer than to retain an existing one, while increasing customer retention by just 5% can boost profits by 25-95%? 

That's why smart Shopify store owners focus on maximizing revenue from existing traffic by increasing their average order value (AOV).

Boosting your Shopify store's AOV is one of the most cost-effective ways to grow your business without spending more on customer acquisition. Let’s see how to get it done! 

10 Proven Strategies on How to Increase Average Order Value on Shopify

Boosting your Average Order Value (AOV) is a powerful way to increase revenue. Here are 10 proven strategies to help you maximize every sale on your Shopify store.

1. Implement Strategic Product Bundling

Product bundling involves grouping complementary items and selling them as a package, typically at a slight discount compared to buying each item separately.

How to Create Effective Bundles:

• Analyze your sales data to identify products frequently purchased together
• Create themed bundles that solve specific customer problems
• Highlight the value proposition by showing the savings compared to individual purchases
• Test different bundle combinations to find what resonates with your audience

Pro Tip: Create "complete solution" bundles that address an entire customer need rather than just grouping similar products. For example, if you sell skincare, bundle a cleanser, toner, moisturizer, and face mask as a "Complete Skincare Ritual" rather than just bundling multiple moisturizers together.

2. Add Upsell and Cross-sell Opportunities

Upselling products encourages customers to purchase a higher-end version of the product they're considering, while cross-selling suggests complementary products.

Shopify makes implementing these strategies straightforward with apps like Bold Upsell or Zipify OneClickUpsell. 

Effective Upselling Techniques:

• Show product comparisons highlighting the benefits of premium options
• Limit the price increase to 25-50% of the original product to maintain conversion rates
• Focus on value rather than price (what additional benefits the customer receives)
• Position upsells at strategic moments in the customer journey

3. Create Tiered Pricing Structures

Tiered pricing allows customers to save more when they purchase in larger quantities. This strategy works particularly well when adding products that are consumable, like supplements, coffee, or skincare items.

How to Implement Tiered Pricing:

• Display the per-unit cost at different quantity thresholds
• Use visual cues to highlight the best value option
• Offer significant enough savings to motivate larger purchases
• Communicate the benefits of buying in bulk (convenience, guaranteed supply)

For example, for stores using private label coffee or supplements, tiered pricing can dramatically increase average order values by encouraging customers to stock up. Coffee retailers implementing tiered pricing have seen up to 40% increases in AOV, as customers recognize the value in purchasing larger quantities to secure consistent morning brews.

4. Establish a Free Shipping Threshold

Setting a free shipping threshold slightly above your current AOV is one of the simplest and most effective ways to increase order values.

Research shows that 93% of online shoppers are more likely to buy more items if free shipping is offered. The psychological allure of "free" is powerful enough to motivate additional purchases.

Tips for Optimizing Your Free Shipping Threshold:

• Set the threshold 15-30% above your current AOV
• Prominently display how much more customers need to spend to qualify
• Suggest specific products that would help them reach the threshold
• Test different threshold levels to find the optimal balance

Understanding your cart abandonment rate can also help determine if your shipping threshold is set appropriately.

5. Implement a Customer Loyalty Program

Loyalty programs encourage repeat purchases and can significantly increase AOV over time. Shopify has several excellent loyalty program apps, like Smile.io or LoyaltyLion, that make implementation simple.

Effective Loyalty Program Elements:

• Points-based systems that reward higher spending
• Tiered membership levels with increasing benefits
• Special perks for VIP customers (early access, exclusive products)
• Double-point events to drive sales during specific periods

Consider offering extra loyalty points for purchasing bundles or crossing certain spending thresholds to directly impact AOV. Here's a battle-tested loyalty framework you can implement today:

6. Utilize Limited-Time Offers and Scarcity

Creating a sense of urgency can motivate customers to increase their cart value to take advantage of special offers before they expire.

Effective Scarcity Tactics:

• Flash sales on complementary products
• Bundle deals available for a limited time
• Countdown timers on special offers
• Limited quantity notifications

7. Optimize Your Product Recommendation Engine

Smart product recommendations can significantly increase cross-selling opportunities. Shopify's native recommendation system is good, but specialized apps like Recobell or LimeSpot can provide more sophisticated personalization.

Keys to Effective Product Recommendations:

• Show truly complementary products, not just popular items
• Personalize recommendations based on browsing history
• Position recommendations at multiple touchpoints (product pages, cart, checkout)
• Test different recommendation algorithms to optimize conversion

8. Create a Post-Purchase Upsell Funnel

The moment immediately after purchase is a golden opportunity for additional sales. Customers have already committed to buying and have their payment information ready.

Post-Purchase Upsell Strategies:

• Offer order-specific add-ons at checkout
• Present one-click upsells on the thank you page
• Send immediate follow-up emails with complementary products
• Provide special offers for fast second purchases

9. Implement Buy-Now, Pay-Later Options

Offering payment flexibility through services like Affirm, Klarna, or Shop Pay Installments can help customers overcome price objections for higher-ticket items.

When customers can spread payments over time, they're often willing to spend more in a single transaction. Shopify stores utilizing BNPL options typically see a 30-50% increase in AOV.

10. Enhance Product Value Perception

Sometimes, increasing AOV is less about tactics and more about fundamentally changing how customers perceive your products' value.

Ways to Enhance Value Perception:

• Improve product photography and video content
•  Expand product descriptions to highlight unique benefits
•  Feature detailed comparison charts for different product tiers
•  Showcase social proof through reviews and testimonials

For stores offering private label pet products or specialty supplements, communicating unique formulations and benefits can justify premium pricing and drive higher order values.

With pet owners spending 35% more per order when they understand ingredient quality differences, detailed explanations of premium ingredients can transform average $32 purchases into $45+ transactions.

Measuring and Optimizing Your AOV Strategies

Implementing these strategies is only the beginning. Consistent measurement and optimization are crucial for long-term AOV growth.

Key Metrics to Track:

• Overall AOV trends over time
• Conversion rates at different price points
• Performance of specific product bundles
• Effectiveness of various upsell offers
• Impact of free shipping thresholds

Use Shopify's analytics dashboard or integrate with Google Analytics for deeper insights. Consider A/B testing different approaches to identify which strategies deliver the best results for your specific store and customer base.

Common AOV Optimization Mistakes to Avoid:

• Pushing too many upsells and creating checkout fatigue
• Setting unrealistic free shipping thresholds
• Creating bundles that don't deliver genuine value
• Neglecting mobile experience in your AOV strategy
• Focusing on AOV at the expense of conversion rate

Tip from the Experts: Use Behavioral Data for Smart Upsell Segmentation

Successful Shopify store owners know that generic upselling doesn’t cut it. To truly boost AOV, it's essential to use advanced behavioral data to create hyper-targeted upsell offers. By analyzing past purchases, browsing behavior, and engagement, it's possible to predict which products will resonate with each customer.

For instance, a customer who frequently views premium products but purchases a budget option could be shown an upsell for a higher-tier version of their recent purchase, not just another low-cost add-on. 

Tools like Klaviyo or LimeSpot allow you to segment your audience and automate tailored offers that feel relevant and personal. This level of personalization doesn’t just increase AOV — it improves the overall customer experience by making upsells feel natural and valuable.

Take Your Shopify Store to the Next Level

Increasing your average order value isn't about tricking customers into spending more—it's about creating genuine value that benefits both your customers and your business. The most successful AOV strategies enhance the customer experience while naturally encouraging larger purchases.

Start by implementing one or two of these strategies, measure their impact, and gradually expand your approach. Many merchants find that selling private-label products on Shopify provides an exceptional opportunity to implement these AOV strategies, as you control pricing structure, product bundling, and value proposition messaging from the ground up

Remember, the goal isn't just higher order values - it's creating a shopping experience so compelling that customers naturally want to purchase more of what you offer. When done right, AOV optimization creates a win-win scenario that fuels sustainable business growth.

‍